Swing Comparison – Arm Position

By | on January 10, 2016 | 22 Comments | FavoriteLoadingAdd to favorites (see below)


lock

Sorry, this content is for members only.

Click here to get access.

 

Already a member? Login below

Email
Password
 
Remember me (for 2 weeks)

Forgot Password





Tags:

Author Description

Paul Wilson

Paul Wilson is the creator of Swing Machine Golf and founder of Ignition Golf. Paul's golf swing technique is based on the Iron Byron swing machine. YouTube Channels: Paul Wilson Golf and Ignition Golf Tips. Please Join me on Google+

22 Responses to “Swing Comparison – Arm Position”

  1. January 10, 2016

    RaymondCHASTEL

    Very interesting comparative video OF MASTER vs PUPIL ,which readily shows on what one should work.
    But it doesn’t tell us ,though ,how you get there ,namely how you Master the ” LATE RELEASE “.
    I’ve been working on the LAG/LATE RELEASE reçently ,with YOUR last video instructions ,And it seems I improve consistently .
    What has MADE me progress the most is being aware And concentrating on the HIP Turn ,from the right foot up ( The right insole as you told me And not the right Heel).I say internally to me ” TURN THE HIPS “.
    it works ..
    I have a question regarding the movement on the hands ( I think we touched on the subject a long Time ago ).
    This aspect is covered in BEN HOGAN’s ” MODERN FUNDAMENTALS OF GOLF ” pages 65 to 70 ,And also in an old manual OF 1946 by ERIC PRAIN ,called ” LIVE HANDS ” : PAUL RUNYAN ,in SHORT GAME SECRETS touched also on the subject .
    It seems that what is important is coordinating the movement OF the hands And the movement OF the shoulders .
    I myself do nothing consciously with m’y hands ,I let them play by themselves ,I’ve always been told that you should let go with the hands And not manipulate them at all .Maybe that’s why I’m So Consistent in m’y shots ,nearly always straight ,but to the expense OF distance .Those people I play with who use hand action seem to shoot all over the place ,Even if thy hit longer than I do .
    What ‘ s YOUR opinion on this question .

    • January 11, 2016

      Paul Wilson

      Raymond,

      This is a comparison tip not a how to do it tip. I think it’s important for people to see what is happening then relate it to their own swing.

      There are tons of tips on all parts of the swing on the site. Surely, people will look them up if they need to work on that specific area of the swing.

      I want you to not hit or help the ball in any way with the hands. The club is mass. If you do not disturb the mass it will go its widest point 100% of the time. This means the release would occur on its own thus consistently squaring the face. You are not trying to hit and see how consistent you are. Most are trying to hit so they manipulate the face. Just a little holding on, rolling over, twitching or wiggling and you will hit it everywhere. This is why I teach powerless arms. The hard part is to get people to trust that a feeling of not hitting with generate even more power than hitting.

  2. January 10, 2016

    LenKoblenz

    Hi Paul,
    I think this tip is marvelous. I love seeing your swing, but seeing it side by side with a swing that needs some work can be very educational. Sometimes I think it will be beneficial to see some swing flaws that may apply to me – some that I will recognize that I “was sure” that I wasn’t doing. I am heading to my back yard.

    Thanks,
    Len

    • January 12, 2016

      Paul Wilson

      Len,

      I thought it would be interesting to compare them. I will be doing a few more in the coming tips.

  3. January 10, 2016

    DanCharpentier

    Loved that,,, really teaches a lot about your method…

    • January 12, 2016

      Paul Wilson

      Dan,

      Glad you liked it. His swing is not all the bad but when you compare it you can really see the differences.

  4. January 10, 2016

    IanCaroline

    Hi Paul,

    Showing the two side by side is a great idea. I look forward to many more.
    In addition to bringing full clarity to the points you have made in the past it is teaching us how to analyse our own swings

    Cheers Ian

  5. Bri

    January 11, 2016

    Bri

    Good analysis and comparison. This has motivated to get out and take some slo-motion video of myself. As painful as it will be watching myself, I know I will learn a lot of what I need to work on. Thank you. Will be looking for more of this analysis and comparison, regarding the lower body movements. Wonderful we live in an age of easy slo-motion video taking.

    • January 12, 2016

      Paul Wilson

      Bri,

      Glad you liked it. Thanks,

      Everyone should be taking video of their swing. There is no excuse nowadays with phones and tablets as well as all of the apps out there.

      Send me your swing and I will do tips comparing yours to mine for everyone.

  6. MatthewHalpin

    January 11, 2016

    MatthewHalpin

    Thought this was great – was hoping you would comment on his legs. I see myself in the movement of the left leg. I am working diligently on the “straight back knee” trigger. Please do more of these, the side by side is really is insightful.

  7. January 11, 2016

    KenPerez

    Paul, one comment about the length of Jim’s swing at the top of back swing i.e., going past parallel. Specifically, is the length the reason he does not maintain his lag angle for he does so half way down i.e., doesn’t appear to be casting. In short, is it possible to maintain a good lag angle in the downswing despite the so called “overswing”? John Daley does this in spades…his club almost touches his left hip in the back swing! Yes, he is a pro, albeit way below his potential,and he probably did this move before he was 5 years old but the long length of back swing isn’t inherently wrong as opposed to the failure to rehinge ones wrists? In addition, everyone, including you, increase the length of the back swing as the clubs get longer, so increasing the length of the swing at the top is a natural attempt to increase distance. Furthermore, in past posts you have said, “The longer the swing arc, the greater the distance”…your thoughts?

    • January 12, 2016

      Paul Wilson

      Ken,

      He’s not casting initially but he is as he keeps coming down. Kind of rare really. Can’t remember anyone ever doing this in the past.

      You sure can keep the lag even with a longer swing. Mickelson is another good example. His driver is way long. Better players will keep the lag.

      I think Daly did it as a kid too without every changing it so he got used to the long swing.

      I let the coil determine my backswing length. Longer clubs create more momentum so they will go back longer on their own. I get lazy and sloppy if I’m not practicing so I have to keep checking it.

  8. January 12, 2016

    ThomasCrank

    Hi Paul,
    Been a member for about a month now and am working on all the positions. My game has made some good improvements, straighter shots, more consistent, confidence, etc. One thing that has not changed is my power. I’m still a lot shorter than the other good players I play with. For example, my 6 iron goes 145 yds, 5-hybrid 155 yds, etc.

    Any thoughts on increasing power? Work on lag? Work on faster swing speed? I can still score with my current length but when my partners are hitting an 8 iron and I have to use a 6 iron, I feel like I am at a disadvantage. Still love the game, but an extra 10 yards per club would really ramp up the confidence! Thanks, really enjoy how you explain the swing in great detail.
    All the best
    Tom

  9. January 13, 2016

    rodbeuthin

    HI Paul

    Great video! I am over swinging just like your student in this video.

    Pete has a video of my swing that I sent in about 2 weeks ago.

    Could you have a look at it please and give me some drills that I can work on. I also have a very bad flying right elbow at the top of the back swing.

    Thanks

    Rod Beuthin

    • January 13, 2016

      Paul Wilson

      Rod,

      Glad you liked it. Thanks.

      I just talked to Pete. Follow what he told you in the video lesson. He is going to send you some links to videos as well.

  10. January 14, 2016

    RobertGibson

    I like all tips you send, but this one with Jim is TERRIFIC.

    Your tip with Jim on head movement is also terrific.

    This type of instruction really helps me, seeing as well as hearing.

    Thanks

You must be logged in to post a comment.